J.P. Morgan Reaches $13 Billion Deal with Justice Department; Is This a Fair Deal?

The Wall Street Journal reported today J.P. Morgan Reaches $13 Billion Tentative Deal with Justice Department. However a criminal investigation is not yet closed.

jp-morganJ.P. Morgan Chase & Co. has reached a tentative deal to pay a record $13 billion to the Justice Department to settle a number of outstanding probes of its residential mortgage-backed securities business, according to a person familiar with the decision.

The deal, which was struck Friday night, doesn’t resolve a continuing criminal probe of the bank’s conduct, which could result in charges against individuals or the bank itself and possibly increase the penalty tab. The two sides continued to disagree over an admission of wrongdoing that would end the criminal probe and decided instead to resolve the civil allegations related to the mortgage securities.

The deal includes $4 billion to settle claims by the Federal Housing Finance Agency that J.P. Morgan misled Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac about the quality of loans it sold them in the run-up to the 2008 financial crisis, another $4 billion in consumer relief, and $5 billion in penalties paid by the bank, according to a second person close to the talks. How the consumer relief and penalties get dispersed and distributed is largely up to the government, and those details are still unclear, this person said.

The tentative settlement comes as J.P. Morgan tries to put as many legal woes behind it as possible. Earlier this week, J.P. Morgan agreed to pay $100 million and acknowledge wrongdoing to settle allegations by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission related to its botched “London whale” trades. Last month, the bank agreed to pay $920 million to settle similar charges with U.S. and U.K. regulators related to that 2012 trade.

The task force issued a series of subpoenas to various financial companies, seeking internal documents. Those documents held a number of promising leads, one of which was assigned to federal prosecutors in Sacramento.

Investigators in that case discovered an email by a bank employee, warning her higher-ups that the bank was vastly overstating the value of the mortgages being securitized, according to people familiar with the probe. That employee, who has since left the company, has been cooperating with federal prosecutors, who expect to call her as a witness if the case ever goes to trial, according to people familiar with the case.

While the Justice Department considers the evidence in that case to be strong, officials at the bank strongly disagree, according to people familiar with the negotiations.

In late September, as the Justice Department neared its own deadline to file a civil lawsuit in the case, the bank offered $3 billion to settle the case. Attorney General Eric Holder rejected that offer, and government lawyers prepared to file the suit. The bank then offered billions more, if the government was willing to throw into the settlement separate cases, raising the total price and resolving more of the bank’s legal headaches.

As the negotiations intensified in September, Mr. Dimon sought a face-to-face meeting with Mr. Holder to try to resolve the remaining sticking points. The two met Sept. 26 at the Justice Department, but the meeting failed to settle the outstanding issues. As talks continued over the remaining weeks, the size of the deal swelled, but the two sides continued to disagree over an admission of wrongdoing that would end the criminal probe.

On Friday night, Mr. Dimon and Mr. Holder decided they were just not going to come to terms on the criminal issue–and take the deal on the terms where they did agree.

Is This a Fair Deal?

For starters, I am astonished at the massive settlement. $13 billion sounds huge (and it is compared to the typical whitewashing affairs we see).

However, things could have been much worse.

CNN Money notes JPM held "$23 billion in reserves for potential litigation expenses. In a footnote to its SEC filing, the bank said legal costs could be nearly $6 billion above that figure in a worst case scenario."

Perhaps $23 billion, $40 billion, or any amount that wipes out JP Morgan litigation reserves is "fair".

Clearly "fair" is in the eyes of the beholder. I will consider it "fair" if executives of the
largest banks are tried and convicted in criminal court. Don't count on it. As astonished as I was about the amount of the settlement, I will be even more astonished if any bank executives are criminally convicted.

Don't forget to Like Freedom Outpost on Facebook, Google Plus, & Twitter.

You can also get Freedom Outpost delivered to your Amazon Kindle device here.

Print pagePDF pageEmail page



  • J J

    This is just as wrong as the Democrat run federal government forcing banks to assimilate other banks or to take bailouts!!! The Democrat run federal government is corrupt and pulls off criminal acts daily!!!

  • junkmailbin

    fair deal?? for morgan yes, for those hurt no. For our gay arab leader yes

  • msbets


  • DonRS

    Now, with this wonderful deal, who will be punished? The people responsible or the stockholders. What a silly question. The stockholders, of course. The one's that had NOTHING to do with the problem. The perpetrators, as usual, who negotiated the deal - get off SCOTT FREE.
    Is this a wonderful country, or what!

  • jlaurie

    Our monster government is confiscating wealth, spread it around (to blacks)

  • lokiswife

    This is another creative accounting scam. Like General Motors, who bragged that they had paid back every cent to the taxpayers who bailed them out, GM received another
    loan "under the table" that allowed them to pay back taxpayers with their own money. The headlines will trumpet the fines, the fines will be paid, not by JP Morgan, but by creative accounting and further loans to JPM. Don't fall for this fake story, designed to show that our government is taking care of taxpayers, it's a political ploy for Obama and a scam for the rest of us.

  • Ray - Jesus is the Son of God.

    Heart Surgery:

    "Tomorrow morning," the Surgeon began,
    "I'll open up your Heart..."

    "You'll find Jesus there," The boy Interrupted..

    The surgeon Looked up, annoyed "I'll
    Cut your heart Open," he continued,
    To see how much damage
    Has been Done..."

    "But when you Open up my heart, you'll
    Find Jesus in There," said the boy.

    The surgeon looked to the parents, who
    Sat quietly. "When I see how much
    Damage has been done, I'll sew your
    Heart and chest back up, and I'll plan
    What to do next."

    "But you'll find Jesus in my heart. The
    Bible says He Lives there. The Hymns all
    say He lives there. You'll find Him in my Heart."

    The surgeon had had enough. "I'll tell you what
    I'll find in your heart. I'll find damaged muscle,
    low blood supply, and weakened vessels. And
    I'll find out if I can make you well."

    "You'll find Jesus there too. He Lives There."
    The surgeon left. He sat in his office, recording his
    notes from the surgery, "....damaged aorta, damaged pulmonary
    Vein, widespread muscle degeneration. No Hope for transplant,
    no hope for cure. Therapy: Painkillers and bed rest.

    Prognosis: Here he paused, "death within one year."
    He stopped the recorder, but There was more to be said.
    "Why?" he asked aloud. "Why did You do this? You've put him here;
    You've put him in this pain; And You've cursed him to an early death. Why?"

    The Lord answered and said, "The boy, My lamb, was not meant for your flock
    for long, for he is a part of My Flock, and will forever be. Here, in My flock, he will
    feel no pain, and will be comforted as you cannot imagine. His parents will one
    day join him here, and they will know peace, and My flock will continue to Grow.."

    The surgeon's tears were hot, but his anger was hotter.
    "You created that boy, and You created that heart.
    He'll be dead in months. Why?"

    The Lord answered, "The boy, My lamb, Shall Return to My flock,
    for he has done his duty: I did not put My lamb with your flock to lose
    him, but to retrieve another lost lamb."

    The Surgeon wept...
    He sat beside the boy's bed; the boy's parents sat across from him.
    When he awoke the boy whispered, "Did you cut open my heart?"
    "Yes," said the surgeon. "What did you find?" asked the boy.

    "I found Jesus there," said the Surgeon..